App icon for MTG Life Counter: Lotus
MTG Life Counter: Lotus Track life and commander damage for up to 10 players
Launch

Toothy, Imaginary Friend
Price tag $8.77

Legendary CreatureIllusion

How it feels to play against

Mildly Annoying Some frustrating moments but still fun.

Popularity

Niche Pick Less common, brings surprise factor.

Ranking

#3051 Current Rank
#3698 Last Week
#2831 Last Month

Videos

Commander gameplay videos featuring Toothy, Imaginary Friend.

Partner Commander

Toothy, Imaginary Friend can partner with Pir, Imaginative Rascal.

High Synergy Cards

Cards that work exceptionally well with Toothy, Imaginary Friend's abilities and overall game plan.

Proft's Eidetic Memory Proft's Eidetic Memory
+52% Synergy $3.16
Psychosis Crawler Psychosis Crawler
+46% Synergy $0.48
Chasm Skulker Chasm Skulker
+44% Synergy $1.01
Windfall Windfall
+43% Synergy $4.14
Teferi's Ageless Insight Teferi's Ageless Insight
+41% Synergy $3.14
Wizard Class Wizard Class
+40% Synergy $0.95
Essence Flux Essence Flux
+39% Synergy $0.77
Tolarian Winds Tolarian Winds
+38% Synergy $0.94
Laboratory Maniac Laboratory Maniac
+36% Synergy $0.97
Jace's Archivist Jace's Archivist
+33% Synergy $8.39

Top Cards

The most popular and reliable cards that form the backbone of successful Toothy, Imaginary Friend decks.

Brainstorm Brainstorm
+31% Synergy $1.29
Ghostly Flicker Ghostly Flicker
+30% Synergy $1.96
Jace, Wielder of Mysteries Jace, Wielder of Mysteries
+26% Synergy $6.44
Frantic Search Frantic Search
+22% Synergy $0.42
Mystic Remora Mystic Remora
+18% Synergy $8.92
Arcane Denial Arcane Denial
+16% Synergy $1.93
High Tide High Tide
+15% Synergy $1.03
Sapphire Medallion Sapphire Medallion
+9% Synergy $4.94
Rapid Hybridization Rapid Hybridization
+9% Synergy $0.86
Counterspell Counterspell
-1% Synergy $1.60

Game Changers

Powerful cards that can single-handedly turn the tide of a game when resolved.

Consecrated Sphinx Consecrated Sphinx
+24% Synergy $33.75
Rhystic Study Rhystic Study
+19% Synergy $53.63
Thassa's Oracle Thassa's Oracle
+17% Synergy $18.92
Force of Will Force of Will
+11% Synergy $62.72
Cyclonic Rift Cyclonic Rift
+9% Synergy $40.86
Ancient Tomb Ancient Tomb
+9% Synergy $98.84
The One Ring The One Ring
+8% Synergy $99.32
Mana Vault Mana Vault
+7% Synergy $86.10
Fierce Guardianship Fierce Guardianship
+3% Synergy $45.55
Mystical Tutor Mystical Tutor
-4% Synergy $14.79

Creatures

Essential creatures that complement Toothy, Imaginary Friend's strategy through synergy, utility, or raw power.

Ledger Shredder Ledger Shredder
+31% Synergy $6.52
Triskaidekaphile Triskaidekaphile
+26% Synergy $0.65
Whirlpool Rider Whirlpool Rider
+26% Synergy $0.19
Body of Knowledge Body of Knowledge
+25% Synergy $0.16
Displacer Kitten Displacer Kitten
+24% Synergy $23.99
Thassa, Deep-Dwelling Thassa, Deep-Dwelling
+23% Synergy $26.89
Oneirophage Oneirophage
+22% Synergy $0.09
Herald of Secret Streams Herald of Secret Streams
+21% Synergy $3.27
Faerie Mastermind Faerie Mastermind
+18% Synergy $21.40
Nadir Kraken Nadir Kraken
+16% Synergy $0.21
Minn, Wily Illusionist Minn, Wily Illusionist
+16% Synergy $6.42
Clinquant Skymage Clinquant Skymage
+16% Synergy $0.10
Spark Double Spark Double
+15% Synergy $11.42
Twenty-Toed Toad Twenty-Toed Toad
+15% Synergy $4.28
Loyal Drake Loyal Drake
+15% Synergy $0.19
Lyla, Holographic Assistant Lyla, Holographic Assistant
+15% Synergy $3.20
Wan Shi Tong, Librarian Wan Shi Tong, Librarian
+14% Synergy $34.44
Whirlpool Drake Whirlpool Drake
+14% Synergy $0.33
Homunculus Horde Homunculus Horde
+13% Synergy $0.72
Snapcaster Mage Snapcaster Mage
+12% Synergy $16.93
Alandra, Sky Dreamer Alandra, Sky Dreamer
+12% Synergy $1.56
Phantasmal Image Phantasmal Image
+12% Synergy $3.63
Vnwxt, Verbose Host Vnwxt, Verbose Host
+12% Synergy $0.30
Defiler of Dreams Defiler of Dreams
+11% Synergy $0.33
Deadeye Navigator Deadeye Navigator
+11% Synergy $3.25
Glasspool Mimic Glasspool Shore Glasspool Mimic
+10% Synergy $4.38
Scrawling Crawler Scrawling Crawler
+10% Synergy $8.07
Arcanis the Omnipotent Arcanis the Omnipotent
+9% Synergy $0.18
Mischievous Mystic Mischievous Mystic
+9% Synergy $0.11
Pollywog Prodigy Pollywog Prodigy
+9% Synergy $7.69
Stunt Double Stunt Double
+9% Synergy $5.92
Mulldrifter Mulldrifter
+8% Synergy $0.09
Flux Channeler Flux Channeler
+8% Synergy $3.45
PuPu UFO PuPu UFO
+8% Synergy $0.29
Lord of the Unreal Lord of the Unreal
+8% Synergy $0.55
Jace's Projection Jace's Projection
+8% Synergy $0.33
Clever Impersonator Clever Impersonator
+7% Synergy $3.54
Archmage Emeritus Archmage Emeritus
+6% Synergy $1.97
Hydroelectric Specimen Hydroelectric Laboratory Hydroelectric Specimen
+6% Synergy $1.29
Wonder Wonder
+6% Synergy $1.17
High Fae Trickster High Fae Trickster
+6% Synergy $11.41
Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel Malcolm, Alluring Scoundrel
+6% Synergy $2.68
Nezahal, Primal Tide Nezahal, Primal Tide
+5% Synergy $8.30
The Unagi of Kyoshi Island The Unagi of Kyoshi Island
+5% Synergy $2.73
Archmage of Runes Archmage of Runes
+4% Synergy $3.54
Archaeomancer Archaeomancer
0% Synergy $0.20
Phyrexian Metamorph Phyrexian Metamorph
-1% Synergy $2.28
Baral, Chief of Compliance Baral, Chief of Compliance
-1% Synergy $2.34
Solemn Simulacrum Solemn Simulacrum
-3% Synergy $0.23
Hullbreaker Horror Hullbreaker Horror
-15% Synergy $5.13

Instants

Key instant-speed responses for protection, removal, and keeping Toothy, Imaginary Friend safe.

Planar Incision Planar Incision
+27% Synergy $0.28
Siren's Ruse Siren's Ruse
+23% Synergy $0.20
Blur Blur
+17% Synergy $0.33
Displace Displace
+15% Synergy $0.44
Foil Foil
+11% Synergy $1.24
Shadow Rift Shadow Rift
+11% Synergy $1.46
Opt Opt
+10% Synergy $0.12
Swan Song Swan Song
+9% Synergy $7.83
Blue Sun's Zenith Blue Sun's Zenith
+9% Synergy $1.25
Aetherize Aetherize
+8% Synergy $0.52
Evacuation Evacuation
+8% Synergy $0.18
Reality Shift Reality Shift
+7% Synergy $0.14
Force of Negation Force of Negation
+7% Synergy $47.15
Pact of Negation Pact of Negation
+7% Synergy $16.16
Flare of Denial Flare of Denial
+7% Synergy $3.97
Teferi's Time Twist Teferi's Time Twist
+7% Synergy $0.30
Snapback Snapback
+7% Synergy $0.19
Snap Snap
+6% Synergy $2.41
Commandeer Commandeer
+6% Synergy $2.12
Illusionist's Stratagem Illusionist's Stratagem
+6% Synergy $0.20
Narset's Reversal Narset's Reversal
+5% Synergy $2.30
Pull from Tomorrow Pull from Tomorrow
+5% Synergy $0.19
Unsummon Unsummon
+5% Synergy $0.22
Dream Fracture Dream Fracture
+5% Synergy $0.12
Brainsurge Brainsurge
+4% Synergy $0.39
Thirst for Discovery Thirst for Discovery
+4% Synergy $0.26
An Offer You Can't Refuse An Offer You Can't Refuse
+3% Synergy $2.29
Mana Drain Mana Drain
+3% Synergy $52.65
Archmage's Charm Archmage's Charm
+3% Synergy $1.25
Mindbreak Trap Mindbreak Trap
+3% Synergy $15.15
Borne Upon a Wind Borne Upon a Wind
+3% Synergy $6.50
Into the Flood Maw Into the Flood Maw
+2% Synergy $3.91
Refute Refute
+2% Synergy $0.09
Quick Study Quick Study
+1% Synergy $0.36
Cryptic Command Cryptic Command
0% Synergy $6.11
Strix Serenade Strix Serenade
0% Synergy $2.94
Mystic Confluence Mystic Confluence
0% Synergy $0.74
Slip Out the Back Slip Out the Back
0% Synergy $3.59
Pongify Pongify
-1% Synergy $1.74
Flusterstorm Flusterstorm
-1% Synergy $8.51
Three Steps Ahead Three Steps Ahead
-1% Synergy $3.87
Unwind Unwind
-2% Synergy $1.36
Consider Consider
-3% Synergy $0.22
Rewind Rewind
-3% Synergy $0.47
Negate Negate
-5% Synergy $0.24
Resculpt Resculpt
-5% Synergy $0.34
Flow of Knowledge Flow of Knowledge
-5% Synergy $0.17
Sink into Stupor Soporific Springs Sink into Stupor
-6% Synergy $7.56
Dramatic Reversal Dramatic Reversal
-10% Synergy $6.70
Muddle the Mixture Muddle the Mixture
-10% Synergy $1.60

Sorceries

Important sorcery spells that advance Toothy, Imaginary Friend's game plan and control the board.

Enter the Enigma Enter the Enigma
+17% Synergy $0.15
Echo of Eons Echo of Eons
+16% Synergy $12.94
Splash Portal Splash Portal
+12% Synergy $1.04
Tezzeret's Gambit Tezzeret's Gambit
+10% Synergy $0.16
Slip Through Space Slip Through Space
+9% Synergy $0.33
Gitaxian Probe Gitaxian Probe
+8% Synergy $3.18
Preordain Preordain
+7% Synergy $0.58
Lórien Revealed Lórien Revealed
+7% Synergy $2.43
Ponder Ponder
+6% Synergy $1.29
Sea Gate Restoration Sea Gate, Reborn Sea Gate Restoration
+6% Synergy $30.36
Enter the Infinite Enter the Infinite
+6% Synergy $5.48
Contentious Plan Contentious Plan
+6% Synergy $0.40
Artful Dodge Artful Dodge
+6% Synergy $0.54
Distortion Strike Distortion Strike
+6% Synergy $0.55
Time Reversal Time Reversal
+6% Synergy $2.14
Game Plan Game Plan
+6% Synergy $0.69
Quasiduplicate Quasiduplicate
+5% Synergy $0.50
Careful Study Careful Study
+5% Synergy $2.16
Winternight Stories Winternight Stories
+5% Synergy $0.92
Compulsive Research Compulsive Research
+5% Synergy $0.04
Lunar Insight Lunar Insight
+5% Synergy $0.23
Treasure Cruise Treasure Cruise
+4% Synergy $0.19
Clear the Mind Clear the Mind
+4% Synergy $0.15
Day's Undoing Day's Undoing
+4% Synergy $1.39
Finale of Revelation Finale of Revelation
+3% Synergy $0.22
River's Rebuke River's Rebuke
+3% Synergy $0.38
Flood of Tears Flood of Tears
+3% Synergy $1.12
Retraced Image Retraced Image
+3% Synergy $8.34
Chart a Course Chart a Course
+2% Synergy $0.14
Serum Visions Serum Visions
+1% Synergy $1.77
Flow of Ideas Flow of Ideas
+1% Synergy $0.36
Irenicus's Vile Duplication Irenicus's Vile Duplication
-1% Synergy $7.59
Spirit Water Revival Spirit Water Revival
-1% Synergy $0.65
Curse of the Swine Curse of the Swine
-2% Synergy $0.17
Merchant Scroll Merchant Scroll
-3% Synergy $6.67
Fabricate Fabricate
-12% Synergy $9.10

Utility Artifacts

Versatile artifacts that provide ongoing value, card selection, or strategic advantages.

Waterbending Scroll Waterbending Scroll
+26% Synergy $0.17
The Ozolith The Ozolith
+25% Synergy $50.14
Teferi's Puzzle Box Teferi's Puzzle Box
+18% Synergy $11.40
Swiftfoot Boots Swiftfoot Boots
+7% Synergy $1.58
Folio of Fancies Folio of Fancies
+7% Synergy $1.22
Trailblazer's Boots Trailblazer's Boots
+7% Synergy $2.37
Shadowspear Shadowspear
+6% Synergy $41.18
The Water Crystal The Water Crystal
+5% Synergy $2.50
Alhammarret's Archive Alhammarret's Archive
+5% Synergy $12.58
Temple Bell Temple Bell
+5% Synergy $5.13
Key to the City Key to the City
+5% Synergy $0.55
Howling Mine Howling Mine
+4% Synergy $6.26
Conjurer's Closet Conjurer's Closet
+4% Synergy $4.83
Brotherhood Regalia Brotherhood Regalia
+4% Synergy $9.99
Winged Boots Winged Boots
+3% Synergy $11.84
Whispersilk Cloak Whispersilk Cloak
+3% Synergy $2.35
Planetarium of Wan Shi Tong Planetarium of Wan Shi Tong
+2% Synergy $4.76
Spellbook Spellbook
+1% Synergy $5.12
Wayfarer's Bauble Wayfarer's Bauble
0% Synergy $0.23
Sensei's Divining Top Sensei's Divining Top
-1% Synergy $34.49
Kefnet's Monument Kefnet's Monument
-1% Synergy $0.39
Bident of Thassa Bident of Thassa
-5% Synergy $0.32
Isochron Scepter Isochron Scepter
-6% Synergy $17.25
Lightning Greaves Lightning Greaves
-11% Synergy $4.38

Enchantments

Powerful enchantments that support Toothy, Imaginary Friend's strategy and create lasting battlefield effects.

Ominous Seas Ominous Seas
+28% Synergy $1.10
Propaganda Propaganda
+11% Synergy $3.23
Psychic Corrosion Psychic Corrosion
+9% Synergy $5.47
Aqueous Form Aqueous Form
+9% Synergy $0.42
Dictate of Kruphix Dictate of Kruphix
+7% Synergy $0.63
Dissipation Field Dissipation Field
+6% Synergy $2.44
Archmage Ascension Archmage Ascension
+6% Synergy $3.92
Standstill Standstill
+6% Synergy $7.60
Sphinx's Tutelage Sphinx's Tutelage
+5% Synergy $3.20
Struggle for Project Purity Struggle for Project Purity
+5% Synergy $1.46
Aether Tunnel Aether Tunnel
+5% Synergy $0.93
Witness Protection Witness Protection
+4% Synergy $0.04
Curiosity Curiosity
+4% Synergy $0.64
Thought Reflection Thought Reflection
+4% Synergy $1.27
Imprisoned in the Moon Imprisoned in the Moon
+3% Synergy $0.18
Back to Basics Back to Basics
+3% Synergy $6.06
As Foretold As Foretold
+3% Synergy $1.63
Teferi's Tutelage Teferi's Tutelage
+3% Synergy $0.35
The Legend of Kuruk Avatar Kuruk The Legend of Kuruk
+3% Synergy $3.83
Mind Over Matter Mind Over Matter
+3% Synergy $42.78
Leyline of Anticipation Leyline of Anticipation
+2% Synergy $11.16
Unstoppable Plan Unstoppable Plan
+1% Synergy $2.09
Mirrormade Mirrormade
0% Synergy $0.86
Omniscience Omniscience
-1% Synergy $5.46

Planeswalkers

Planeswalkers that work alongside Toothy, Imaginary Friend to provide ongoing value and board presence.

Teferi, Temporal Pilgrim Teferi, Temporal Pilgrim
+19% Synergy $3.67
Teferi, Master of Time Teferi, Master of Time
+10% Synergy $8.63
Jace, the Mind Sculptor Jace, the Mind Sculptor
+8% Synergy $18.38
Mordenkainen Mordenkainen
+8% Synergy $0.95
Narset, Parter of Veils Narset, Parter of Veils
+3% Synergy $1.24
Jace Beleren Jace Beleren
+3% Synergy $1.88

Utility Lands

Non-basic lands that offer additional utility beyond just mana production.

Reliquary Tower Reliquary Tower
+31% Synergy $3.28
Rogue's Passage Rogue's Passage
+27% Synergy $0.27
Lonely Sandbar Lonely Sandbar
+14% Synergy $0.11
Cephalid Coliseum Cephalid Coliseum
+13% Synergy $0.18
Mikokoro, Center of the Sea Mikokoro, Center of the Sea
+8% Synergy $5.98
Geier Reach Sanitarium Geier Reach Sanitarium
+7% Synergy $0.64
Otawara, Soaring City Otawara, Soaring City
+6% Synergy $20.40
Forge of Heroes Forge of Heroes
+6% Synergy $0.63
Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx
+5% Synergy $45.08
Emergence Zone Emergence Zone
+5% Synergy $4.45
Desert of the Mindful Desert of the Mindful
+5% Synergy $0.11
High Market High Market
+5% Synergy $1.12
Sanctum of Eternity Sanctum of Eternity
+5% Synergy $7.65
Halimar Depths Halimar Depths
+4% Synergy $0.22
Scavenger Grounds Scavenger Grounds
+4% Synergy $0.59
Agna Qel'a Agna Qel'a
+4% Synergy $0.98
Remote Isle Remote Isle
+4% Synergy $0.11
Ghost Quarter Ghost Quarter
+4% Synergy $0.82
Command Beacon Command Beacon
+3% Synergy $5.66
War Room War Room
+2% Synergy $5.27
Minamo, School at Water's Edge Minamo, School at Water's Edge
+2% Synergy $50.05
Temple of the False God Temple of the False God
+2% Synergy $0.11
Terrain Generator Terrain Generator
+2% Synergy $2.13
Mystic Sanctuary Mystic Sanctuary
+1% Synergy $5.01
Castle Vantress Castle Vantress
0% Synergy $0.20
Karn's Bastion Karn's Bastion
0% Synergy $1.38
Rivendell Rivendell
-1% Synergy $1.50
Mistrise Village Mistrise Village
-1% Synergy $6.36
Urza's Saga Urza's Saga
-3% Synergy $35.94

Mana Artifacts

Artifacts focused on mana acceleration and color fixing for consistent gameplay.

Thought Vessel Thought Vessel
+27% Synergy $1.71
Mind Stone Mind Stone
+14% Synergy $0.23
Midnight Clock Midnight Clock
+13% Synergy $0.53
Decanter of Endless Water Decanter of Endless Water
+10% Synergy $5.11
Arcane Signet Arcane Signet
+9% Synergy $0.32
Fellwar Stone Fellwar Stone
+7% Synergy $0.72
Liquimetal Torque Liquimetal Torque
+6% Synergy $4.51
Prismatic Lens Prismatic Lens
+6% Synergy $0.69
Chrome Mox Chrome Mox
+3% Synergy $115.71
Throne of Eldraine Throne of Eldraine
+3% Synergy $31.84
Extraplanar Lens Extraplanar Lens
+3% Synergy $8.99
Mox Diamond Mox Diamond
+3% Synergy $832.25
Jeweled Lotus Jeweled Lotus
+3% Synergy $42.22
Bender's Waterskin Bender's Waterskin
+2% Synergy $0.53
Sol Ring Sol Ring
+1% Synergy $1.04
Commander's Sphere Commander's Sphere
+1% Synergy $0.17
Grim Monolith Grim Monolith
+1% Synergy $399.08
Sceptre of Eternal Glory Sceptre of Eternal Glory
+1% Synergy $16.99
Sky Diamond Sky Diamond
0% Synergy $0.21
Lotus Petal Lotus Petal
0% Synergy $33.69
Everflowing Chalice Everflowing Chalice
-1% Synergy $0.23
Gilded Lotus Gilded Lotus
-2% Synergy $0.88
Caged Sun Caged Sun
-2% Synergy $3.30
Mox Amber Mox Amber
-2% Synergy $65.66
Thran Dynamo Thran Dynamo
-3% Synergy $3.55

Lands

The mana base foundation for Toothy, Imaginary Friend decks, ensuring smooth and reliable mana development.

Glasspool Mimic Glasspool Shore Glasspool Mimic
+10% Synergy $4.38
Opal Palace Opal Palace
+7% Synergy $0.11
Sea Gate Restoration Sea Gate, Reborn Sea Gate Restoration
+6% Synergy $30.36
Hydroelectric Specimen Hydroelectric Laboratory Hydroelectric Specimen
+6% Synergy $1.29
Flooded Strand Flooded Strand
+4% Synergy $14.36
Scalding Tarn Scalding Tarn
+4% Synergy $26.93
Misty Rainforest Misty Rainforest
+4% Synergy $25.95
Cavern of Souls Cavern of Souls
+4% Synergy $42.67
Polluted Delta Polluted Delta
+3% Synergy $16.58
Prismatic Vista Prismatic Vista
+3% Synergy $30.30
Island Island
-1% Synergy $0.15
Snow-Covered Island Snow-Covered Island
-1% Synergy $0.81
Myriad Landscape Myriad Landscape
-4% Synergy $0.21
Sink into Stupor Soporific Springs Sink into Stupor
-6% Synergy $7.56

Similar Commanders

The following Commanders share a similar playing style, strategy, or theme like Toothy, Imaginary Friend.